The altercation led to four red cards, and the FA has informed both clubs that they are likely to be fined for failing to control their players, in violation of FA Rule E20, which mandates that clubs ensure their players conduct themselves in an orderly manner during matches.
The drama started with a dramatic 98th-minute volley from James Tarkowski, which survived a VAR review and gave Everton a crucial victory over their rivals. The moment was particularly emotional for Everton fans, as it marked the last Merseyside derby at Goodison Park, their home for 132 years. Abdoulaye Doucoure, caught up in the celebration, rushed toward the Liverpool supporters, prompting Curtis Jones to react aggressively. This led to a clash between the two players, with teammates attempting to separate them. Referee Michael Oliver issued second yellow cards to both Doucoure and Jones, resulting in their ejections from the match.
The tensions did not stop there. After the final whistle, Liverpool’s head coach Arne Slot approached referee Michael Oliver, presumably to voice his displeasure with the officiating, which led to Slot receiving a straight red card. His assistant coach, Sipke Hulshoff, was also sent off under similar circumstances. Hackett, the former PGMOL chief, emphasized that this loss of discipline during such a high-stakes match marred what should have been a thrilling encounter, further fueling the notion that both clubs failed to keep their players in check.
The FA’s Rule E20 specifically addresses the issue of misconduct, stating that clubs can be sanctioned if they allow players to engage in disorderly behavior on the field. In previous instances, the FA has fined clubs for similar offenses. For example, in October 2024, Chelsea and Nottingham Forest both faced fines for player confrontations during a match at Stamford Bridge. When a team accumulates six or more yellow or red cards in a single match, they automatically meet the criteria for additional disciplinary measures, including financial penalties.
In the Merseyside derby, Liverpool received yellow cards for three players—Andy Robertson, Conor Bradley, and Curtis Jones (who was booked twice)—while red cards were shown to Slot and Hulshoff. As this is the first time both teams have been involved in such an incident, they are expected to receive a £25,000 fine. The fine is based on the fact that both clubs met the criteria set by the FA due to the number of cards shown during the match.
Further complicating matters, Everton supporters spilled onto the pitch during the celebrations following Tarkowski’s goal, an act that could lead to further repercussions under FA Rule E20. The rule also holds clubs accountable for their supporters’ behavior, including any criminal activities committed by individuals on the pitch. This could result in criminal investigations and additional fines for the clubs. As a result, both Everton and Liverpool now face a range of potential penalties for the events that unfolded during what was supposed to be a historic and emotional Merseyside derby.
