I’ve noticed a lot of fans still complaining about Manchester United not signing a top midfielder this summer, and honestly, it makes me wonder if some people truly understand how long rebuilding a club like ours takes. There’s a belief floating around that one transfer window can suddenly solve all of United’s problems, but that’s simply not how football works. A single window can improve the squad, yes, but structural issues that have built up over years don’t vanish overnight.
Let’s start by addressing the most obvious problem from last season: scoring goals. United created chances, but we consistently struggled to convert them. Week after week, we saw games slip away simply because our finishing lacked the sharpness required at the highest level. Defending well and maintaining a solid structure are important, but football ultimately comes down to putting the ball in the net. That’s why this summer, the club’s emphasis on strengthening the attack makes perfect sense.
This window, we’ve signed two world-class forwards who bring a combination of speed, skill, and proven goal-scoring ability. On top of that, a promising young striker has been added to the squad — someone who can grow into a key player for years to come. These moves are clearly aimed at addressing the single biggest weakness from last season: our lack of firepower. What we’re seeing is strategic, long-term planning rather than a desperate short-term fix.
It’s not just about new attacking talent, though. This window has also seen a cleansing of sorts. Players with negative attitudes or bloated wages have been moved on, sending a strong message that culture and mentality matter as much as skill. Football is as much a mental game as it is a physical one, and having a harmonious dressing room is crucial to long-term success. The club seems committed to creating an environment where players are accountable, motivated, and aligned with the manager’s vision.
Another smart move has been improving the goalkeeper position. A young, promising keeper has been brought in who could realistically serve the club for a decade. This is a strategic investment in stability. A reliable goalkeeper can be the difference between a mid-table finish and a title challenge, and this signing reflects a forward-thinking approach.
The club has also dealt with the so-called “bomb squad” — players who were liabilities on and off the pitch. Most of them are now gone, with only Malacia remaining. He isn’t a troublemaker; he simply doesn’t fit the manager’s plans. This shows that the club is willing to make tough decisions rather than keeping players for reputation or past contributions. Prioritizing alignment with the manager’s vision over short-term comfort is exactly what a club rebuilding for the future needs.
Of course, it would have been ideal to also secure a top midfielder, and missing out on names like Donnarumma or Martinez is a disappointment. These players could have elevated the squad further, and their absence prevents this window from being rated a perfect 9/10. But despite that, I would still give this window an 8/10. The foundations for meaningful progress have been laid. The club isn’t just adding names; there’s a coherent strategy behind every decision.
It’s important to understand that United’s problems are systemic. They are deep-rooted and cannot be resolved in a single window. Rebuilding a club of this stature requires patience, careful planning, and a series of smart, well-targeted moves across multiple seasons. One summer of transfer activity will never fix long-standing structural issues, and anyone expecting immediate perfection is setting themselves up for frustration. What we’re witnessing now is the start of a proper process — a process where the board, the manager, and the staff are aligned and focused on the right priorities: building a competitive team that can consistently challenge at the top level.
Another positive shift is evident at the executive level. For too long, decisions appeared to be driven more by branding, marketing, or social media presence than by footballing logic. This summer, however, it seems that the priority is squarely on the team’s performance on the pitch. That subtle but crucial change in focus can have a huge long-term impact, because success is built on the field, not in follower counts or sponsorship deals.
Looking ahead, it’s clear that another big transfer window will be necessary next year. Rebuilding a squad capable of consistently competing for titles is a multi-year project. The current window lays the groundwork, but continued smart recruitment will be vital. Fans need to understand that patience isn’t optional; it’s part of the plan.
Meanwhile, supporters also have a role to play. Criticism is natural, but relentless negativity doesn’t help anyone. Backing Rúben Amorim, supporting the new players, and focusing on results rather than dwelling on what hasn’t happened yet will help the squad build confidence and momentum. Constructive engagement is part of being a true fan — shouting about missing players endlessly doesn’t move the club forward.
Yes, this window isn’t perfect, and there are still areas for improvement. But let’s be honest about the progress made: key weaknesses have been addressed, negative influences removed, promising young talent added, and the strategic focus of the club has shifted toward football rather than image. These are meaningful steps forward that deserve recognition.
For now, the responsibility falls to all of us — fans, players, and management — to move forward together. Supporting the manager, backing the squad, and focusing on performance are the things we can influence directly. Change won’t happen overnight, but the direction we’re heading is cause for optimism. This transfer window deserves an 8/10, and with continued patience, smart recruitment, and unity, the coming seasons could see Manchester United back at the top where it belongs.
