Barcelona have been hit with yet another injury setback as young left-back Alejandro Balde is ruled out for around three weeks due to a hamstring problem. The talented defender, who has become a cornerstone in Barça’s backline, will miss some key fixtures, including the highly anticipated Champions League clash against Newcastle United on September 18. His absence leaves Hansi Flick with a major selection headache, particularly given Barcelona’s need for both defensive stability and attacking width down the left flank.
In response to this situation, fans have begun suggesting unconventional solutions, with one idea standing out above the rest: deploying winger Raphinha as a temporary left-back. Though it sounds unusual, many supporters believe the Brazilian’s pace, technical skill, and tireless work rate could allow him to slot into the role effectively, especially in a high-intensity European fixture. Social media platforms quickly lit up with debates, as supporters weighed the risks and rewards of such an experiment.
One fan boldly stated, “Call me crazy, but if Balde is out for Newcastle away, I’d play Raphinha at left-back, Rashford on the wing, and Christensen at LCB. I can’t even imagine Gerard Martínez handling Elanga in a high line.” Another echoed the sentiment, saying they would fully back the move, while a third commenter explained a detailed tactical reshuffle involving Raphinha at left-back, Rashford taking the wide role, and either Dani Olmo or Fermín López playing as the creative No. 10. These comments reveal not just creativity, but also the deep tactical engagement Barcelona fans often bring to discussions around the team.
However, not everyone was convinced. Some fans argued that Raphinha’s offensive instincts make him a liability in a defensive role, particularly against a physically intense side like Newcastle. One supporter flatly rejected the idea, insisting that Christensen or even another defensive-minded option should fill in at left-back instead. Others mocked the thought of playing an attack-focused player in such a crucial position, warning that it could leave Barcelona exposed in a match where discipline and structure will be key.
This debate highlights a recurring theme in modern football: the blurring of positional lines. Managers and fans alike are increasingly open to experimenting with versatile players in unconventional roles. While Raphinha’s qualities may suit a makeshift defensive role in theory, the practical risks of deploying him there in a Champions League knockout-level environment are significant. Whether Hansi Flick will be bold enough to try it remains to be seen, but one thing is certain — Balde’s injury has forced Barcelona into a tactical dilemma that will test the squad’s depth and the manager’s ingenuity.
