Former Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has sparked major controversy after his brutally honest remarks about Liverpool’s latest signing, describing his recent performances as “like a kid playing against men.”
The comment came during Scholes’ post-match analysis following Liverpool’s most recent outing, where the young player struggled to make an impact. Known for his straightforward and often unforgiving assessments, Scholes didn’t hold back — calling out what he saw as a lack of physicality, composure, and readiness for Premier League intensity.
“He looked completely out of his depth tonight,” Scholes said. “It’s as if he’s not used to this level — like a kid trying to keep up with grown men. Liverpool need more from a player wearing that shirt.”
Fans Divided Over Harsh Remarks
Scholes’ comments quickly went viral, drawing mixed reactions across social media. Some fans agreed with his evaluation, admitting the new signing appeared overwhelmed and lacked confidence. Others, however, slammed the former midfielder for being unnecessarily cruel, arguing that the player needs time to adapt to Liverpool’s system under Arne Slot.
One supporter wrote, “Scholes was way out of line — it’s his first few games, not everyone adapts instantly.” Another added, “He’s young, learning, and will only get better with experience. Scholes should know that better than anyone.”
Pressure Mounts on Liverpool’s New Arrival
The criticism comes at a challenging time for the young signing, who has been under intense scrutiny since his high-profile move to Anfield. Despite flashes of talent, inconsistency and nerves have crept into his performances — something Slot and his coaching staff are reportedly addressing behind the scenes.
Liverpool insiders remain confident in the player’s potential, emphasizing that his technical ability and work rate will eventually shine through once he settles into the rhythm of English football.
A Reality Check or Too Harsh?
While Paul Scholes’ remarks have certainly added pressure, they may also serve as motivation for the player to prove his critics wrong. Many believe that adversity can often be the spark that helps young talents rise to the occasion — and Anfield has seen countless examples of players silencing their doubters.
For now, the debate rages on: was Scholes simply telling the truth, or did he go too far in his criticism?
Either way, Liverpool fans — and the football world — will be watching closely to see how the young star responds in the matches to come.
