The Premier League has officially addressed the two major penalty controversies that overshadowed Liverpool’s recent clash with Brentford — decisions that left both players and fans furious.
In a detailed post-match statement, league officials explained why Liverpool were denied a penalty after Cody Gakpowent down inside the area, while Brentford were awarded one for a foul that appeared to occur outside the box.
According to the Premier League’s clarification, the decision not to award Liverpool a spot-kick stemmed from what was deemed “minimal contact” on Gakpo, with VAR concluding that the on-field decision of no penalty should stand. The statement added that there was not enough “clear and obvious error” to overturn the referee’s call.
However, the ruling that gave Brentford a penalty moments later drew even greater outrage. Replays clearly showed the initial contact took place just outside the penalty area, yet the referee pointed to the spot — a decision the Premier League has now admitted was “an error in judgment.”
As a result of the officiating inconsistencies, reports confirm that the referee has been replaced for the upcoming Premier League fixtures pending internal review by the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited).
Liverpool fans have been vocal about the perceived bias and lack of accountability, calling for more transparency in VAR operations. The club itself has reportedly sought clarification over several recent refereeing decisions that have gone against them in key moments this season.
The controversy adds to Liverpool’s frustrations after another disappointing performance, leaving supporters wondering how many more results could be swayed by refereeing calls rather than footballing merit.
