The Premier League is once again at the center of a VAR controversy after the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited) admitted to a major officiating mistake during the December 4, 2024, clash between Newcastle United and Liverpool at St. James’ Park. Fans of both teams have reacted angrily, calling it one of the worst VAR blunders in the history of the league.
The Controversial Incident
The drama unfolded in the 78th minute when Newcastle’s Bruno Guimarães made a high tackle on Liverpool’s Curtis Jones. The challenge, which connected above the ankle, appeared to be both dangerous and reckless—suggesting a clear red-card offense. However, referee Andy Madley issued only a yellow card, and VAR did not recommend a review of the incident. As a result, Guimarães remained on the field and played a key role in Newcastle’s push for a late result.
PGMOL Admits Mistake
After the match, the PGMOL issued a statement acknowledging the error. “After a detailed review, it has been concluded that a red card should have been given for the tackle on Curtis Jones. The VAR team did not follow the correct procedures in assessing the severity of the incident,” the statement read.
The admission has sparked widespread anger, with social media flooded with calls for accountability. Hashtags such as #VARCorruption and #JusticeForLiverpool trended, with many fans accusing the system of damaging the integrity of the game.
A Thrilling Match Despite the Controversy
Despite the officiating drama, the match itself was a captivating spectacle, ending in a 3-3 draw. Liverpool showed resilience, coming back twice from behind, with Curtis Jones and Mohamed Salah (scoring twice) leading the charge. The Reds dominated possession (62% to Newcastle’s 38%) and had 19 shots compared to Newcastle’s 13, but defensive mistakes cost them dearly.
Newcastle’s goals came from Anthony Gordon and a brace by Alexander Isak. An equalizer in the 89th minute, following an error by Liverpool goalkeeper Caoimhin Kelleher, earned the Magpies a point. Kelleher, who had previously made crucial saves, was criticized for the mistake.
Calls for Change
Football pundits quickly condemned the officiating. Jamie Carragher called the VAR decision “a disgrace,” while Alan Shearer described it as “unacceptable.” Fans have joined in, demanding better training for referees and independent oversight of VAR to prevent such errors in the future.
Impact on the Season
This incident has raised wider concerns about the Premier League’s officiating standards. The role of VAR, intended to correct clear mistakes, has come under scrutiny after failing to do so in such a significant moment. With Liverpool’s lead at the top of the table now reduced to just seven points after 14 games, they may feel this error could affect the title race.
For Newcastle, the draw keeps them in the hunt for European qualification, but the controversy over the officiating looms over their season.
Looking Ahead
As the pressure mounts for accountability, both the Premier League and PGMOL will need to act swiftly to address these concerns. The integrity of English football is on the line, and decisive steps are required to restore trust in the officiating system.
