“First and foremost, let’s not misinterpret me—Marcus Rashford is undoubtedly a top-class player. He has raw pace, flair, and the potential to be one of the most dangerous forwards in Europe when used properly. But when you look at Barcelona’s current state, the conversation shifts from individual talent to strategic fit.
Right now, Barça doesn’t just need players who can make headlines—they need players who can reshape their footballing identity. It’s no longer about who is the fastest or most technically gifted. It’s about who understands the nuances of the game, who sees beyond the moment and plays two or three moves ahead. That’s why, if I had the responsibility of a sporting director, my choice wouldn’t be Rashford—it would be Julian Alvarez.
Julian is not your typical modern attacker who thrives only in chaos. He’s a rare breed of footballer—a tactician on the pitch. His ability to read the game, both in possession and in transitions, is something you usually see in seasoned managers. He’s always scanning, always anticipating, and he adjusts his positioning based on where the game is heading, not just where the ball is.
He doesn’t need to be the flashiest player on the pitch to control the match—his intelligence, movement off the ball, and his subtle but effective decisions are what give shape to his team’s rhythm. He can play behind the striker, as a second striker, or drop into midfield to overload and create. That tactical versatility, combined with a natural leadership presence, makes him invaluable. Even without wearing the armband, you can see teammates responding to his tempo and intent.
But here’s the real issue—Barcelona has lost its identity over the last few years. They’ve chased star power instead of footballing coherence. That’s why I say, unless the club establishes a clear, well-thought-out project, I would never consider returning. Not because of emotion or loyalty—but because modern football punishes confusion. You can’t build a successful team by collecting names. You build it by defining who you are, then finding the right players who embody that philosophy.
If Barça wants to rise again—not just temporarily, but sustainably—they need to focus on building the brain of the team before polishing its face. Intelligence, structure, and purpose must come before style and stardom. Buy the mind, then the magic will follow.
