legend though he’s respected by both sets of fans for different reasons.
Here’s why:
Arsenal
Time at club: 2004–2012 (8 seasons)
Impact: Scored 132 goals in 278 appearances, won the FA Cup (2005), and became club captain.
Legacy: Known for his stunning goals, technical brilliance, and carrying the team during his final season, winning the Premier League Golden Boot (2011/12).
Emotional connection: Fans saw him as the heir to Bergkamp and Henry until his controversial move to Man United.
Manchester United
Time at club: 2012–2015 (3 seasons)
Impact: Scored 58 goals in 105 games.
Highlight: Almost single-handedly fired United to the 2012/13 Premier League title with 26 goals Sir Alex Ferguson’s last season.
Legacy: United fans see him as a short-term hero who delivered an immediate league title.
Verdict:
Arsenal: Long-term service, emotional bond, world-class performances legend status despite the controversial exit.
Man United: Short stay but massive impact cult hero, not quite a full legend.