Current Goalkeeping Situation
Manchester United’s goalkeeping situation is uncertain, with both Onana and Bayindir having their strengths and weaknesses. Onana has shown promise and relative consistency, boasting 9 clean sheets in the 2024/2025 season, which puts him joint fifth in the Premier League rankings. Meanwhile, Bayindir has struggled to impress, and his error against Arsenal raised concerns about his ability to perform under pressure.
Why Onana Should Start
There are several reasons why Onana should start as the number one goalkeeper for Manchester United:
- Experience: Onana has gained valuable experience playing for Manchester United and has been part of the team for some big games. This experience will undoubtedly benefit him in high-pressure situations.
- Statistics: Onana has a decent save percentage and has made some crucial saves for the team. His statistics indicate that he’s capable of delivering solid performances.
- Current Form: Although Onana has faced criticism, he has shown glimpses of brilliance and has the potential to grow and improve. With the right support and guidance, Onana can develop into a top-class goalkeeper.
Potential Challenges
While Onana seems to be the more likely candidate to start, there are potential challenges that could affect his position:
- Competition: Manchester United’s interest in signing new goalkeepers like Gianluigi Donnarumma, David De Gea, and others could threaten Onana’s position as number one. If the club signs a top-class goalkeeper, Onana might find himself on the bench.
- Performance: Onana needs to maintain his form and consistency to secure his spot as the number one goalkeeper. Any dip in performance could lead to him being replaced by Bayindir or a new signing.
Bayindir’s Prospects
While Onana seems to be the more likely candidate to start, Bayindir has his own strengths that could make him a viable option:
- Clean Sheet Record: Bayindir boasts a commendable record from his time at Fenerbahçe, with 53 clean sheets in 166 career appearances. This indicates that he’s capable of delivering consistent performances.
- Potential: Bayindir’s performance metrics suggest that he could offer a steadier presence if given more game time. Providing him with opportunities could help stabilize the team’s defensive efforts.
Ruben Amorim’s Plans
The Manchester United boss, Ruben Amorim, seems to be looking to the transfer market to solve the club’s goalkeeping issues. With the potential departure of Bayindir and the interest in signing new goalkeepers, Onana’s position is uncertain. Amorim’s plans will likely dictate the club’s goalkeeping situation, and it will be interesting to see how he approaches this challenge ¹.
In conclusion, while both Onana and Bayindir have their strengths and weaknesses, Onana seems to be the more likely candidate to start as the number one goalkeeper for Manchester United. However, the club’s interest in signing new goalkeepers and Bayindir’s potential could change the dynamics of the goalkeeping situation. Ultimately, the decision will depend on the club’s transfer plans and the performances of both goalkeepers in the upcoming season.
