Virgil van Dijk Deserves More Credit: Why Liverpool’s Captain Is Under Unfair Scrutiny

Virgil van Dijk Deserves More Credit: Why Liverpool’s Captain Is Under Unfair Scrutiny

Virgil van Dijk, Liverpool’s towering captain, has faced a barrage of criticism in recent weeks, with pundits quick to highlight perceived lapses in form. Headlines have painted a picture of a defender in decline—claiming he’s making more mistakes, losing his commanding presence, and even underperforming as a leader. Yet much of this scrutiny appears overstated, with the reality telling a very different story.

After Liverpool’s 3-0 defeat at the Etihad, Van Dijk was once again thrust into the spotlight. Wayne Rooney suggested the Dutchman “hasn’t been at that level this season,” while Alan Shearer described him as “really poor” against Manchester City. Gary Neville chimed in, questioning Van Dijk’s defending on a specific goal. These critiques, amplified by mainstream media, have seeped into the general footballing discourse, creating the perception that Van Dijk is struggling.

But when we look closely at the numbers, a different picture emerges. Statistically, Van Dijk remains one of the most reliable defenders in the Premier League. He has not made a major error this season, and his defensive metrics—including clearances, blocks, and aerial duels won—are as strong as, if not better than, last year. Remarkably, he has been dribbled past just once all season. A few weeks ago, Van Dijk was praised for consistently covering for his defensive partner, Ibrahima Konate, showing the same composure and reliability that earned him world-class status.

Liverpool head coach Arne Slot also weighed in, highlighting that Van Dijk sets exceptionally high standards. “He sets the bar at 10 out of 10, and when he delivers nine out of 10, he is criticized,” Slot explained. While other players are lauded for near-perfect performances, Van Dijk is held to an almost impossible benchmark. Former Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher has previously hailed Van Dijk as one of the club’s all-time greats, alongside Steven Gerrard, Sir Kenny Dalglish, and John Barnes, reaffirming his enduring status.

It’s true that Van Dijk has experienced a minor dip in form between the October and November international breaks. He was caught out for Bryan Mbuemo’s goal against Manchester United and appeared off his usual commanding self against Brentford. But these moments are fleeting in the context of a long season. Even amid these challenges, he shone in victories over Aston Villa and Real Madrid.

Critics often overlook the broader context of Liverpool’s current struggles. The team has been disjointed this season, impacting several key players—Mohamed Salah, Alexis Mac Allister, and Konate included. Van Dijk’s temporary struggles are more a reflection of systemic issues than individual decline. Defensive inconsistencies from Milos Kerkez at left-back, the absence of Ryan Gravenberch in midfield, and tactical adjustments after the summer signings have all contributed to exposing Van Dijk and the backline.

In reality, Van Dijk remains the most dependable figure in Liverpool’s defense. Despite media scrutiny, his leadership, experience, and composure continue to anchor the team. As Liverpool navigates a challenging run of fixtures, it is clear that the captain deserves measured recognition for his contributions rather than disproportionate criticism.

In short, Virgil van Dijk is not faltering—he is a world-class defender enduring the natural ebb and flow of a long football season. What he truly needs is understanding and support, not constant critique from pundits eager for headlines.