Chelsea have been advised to rethink their midfield transfer plans ahead of the January transfer window, with former Blues striker Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink believing that Martin Zubimendi would be a much better signing than Bournemouth midfielder Alex Scott.
The debate is becoming interesting because Chelsea have continued investing heavily in young footballers, building a squad filled with exciting talents who have enormous potential. However, Hasselbaink believes there is something important missing from the current project: experience, leadership and players who already know what it takes to win major trophies.
Hasselbaink explained his position:
“Alex Scott is obviously a top player, but I would prefer somebody with a little bit more experience because we have so many young players in the squad.
“If they can go out and get Martin Zubimendi from Arsenal, then they should absolutely go and get him.”
His message is clear: Chelsea do not necessarily need another talented youngster who will require time to develop. They need somebody capable of walking into the starting XI and immediately raising the standard of the team.
WHY ZUBIMENDI COULD BE THE PERFECT SIGNING
The Spanish midfielder possesses qualities that could make a significant difference at Stamford Bridge.
His ability to control possession, dictate the tempo, distribute the ball under pressure and protect the defence makes him an attractive option for a manager who wants his team to dominate matches.
Zubimendi also has experience working with Xabi Alonso at Real Sociedad, meaning there is already familiarity with the Spanish football philosophy Alonso could want to implement at Chelsea.
His international pedigree is another major attraction, having won the European Championship and World Cup with Spain.
Hasselbaink believes those achievements and his experience at the highest level would give Chelsea something their current midfield desperately needs.
ALEX SCOTT IS TALENTED, BUT IS HE WHAT CHELSEA NEED RIGHT NOW?
There is absolutely no doubt about Scott’s potential.
The Bournemouth midfielder is technically gifted, energetic, intelligent on the ball and capable of contributing in different midfield roles. At just 23, he still has plenty of room to develop into an outstanding Premier League midfielder.
Chelsea have previously been linked with him, and his profile fits the club’s recruitment strategy of identifying young players before they reach their peak.
However, that is precisely where Hasselbaink’s concern comes from.
Chelsea already have several young players who are still developing. Adding another midfielder with a similar profile might strengthen the squad for the future, but would it solve the immediate problems?
That is the question the club must answer.
THE BIG QUESTION FOR XABI ALONSO
If Chelsea genuinely want to compete for the Premier League and Champions League again, they cannot build their entire project around potential.
They need a balance between young talents and experienced winners. They need players who can handle pressure, control difficult matches and help younger teammates understand what winning consistently requires.
Zubimendi could offer that balance, while Scott represents a potentially exciting long-term investment.
Of course, convincing Arsenal to sell an important midfielder to a London rival would be a completely different challenge. His availability and willingness to leave would also need to be established. A transfer should not be treated as guaranteed.
MY TAKE:
I actually understand Hasselbaink’s argument.
Chelsea have enough exciting young players. What they need now is a few experienced footballers who can bring composure, authority and consistency to the team.
Alex Scott would be a fantastic addition, but Zubimendi could bring a different level of experience and tactical intelligence to the midfield.
If both players were genuinely available at reasonable prices, I would lean towards Zubimendi for Chelsea’s immediate needs.
But would Arsenal really allow one of their midfielders to join Chelsea?
CHELSEA FANS, WHO WOULD YOU CHOOSE?
MARTIN ZUBIMENDI
ALEX SCO